A critically admired family tragedy about integrity, sacrifice and the cost of easy money in 1986 Queens, with no sex or nudity, held back by strong language including Jesus' name as an exclamation and a restrained streak of violence.
Paper Tiger is a crime drama written and directed by James Gray, set in 1986 Queens, and drawn from his own childhood in a Russian-Jewish neighborhood. Neon opens it in select US theaters on November 13, 2026, before a wide release on November 20. It premiered in competition for the Palme d'Or at Cannes on May 16, where it received a ten-minute standing ovation, and it opened the 2026 New York Film Festival. It is rated R for language and some violence, per Movie Insider, runs 1 hour 55 minutes, and has a Metascore of about 80 from 26 critics on Metacritic. The Hollywood Reporter called it an operatically intense crime drama, and the film is also a domestic drama that draws on Gray's own family, per The Hollywood Reporter.
Adam Driver plays Gary Pearl, a retired NYPD detective who has done well for himself and drives a flashy Mercedes, and Miles Teller plays his younger brother Irwin, an engineer whose oldest son is about to leave for college. Scarlett Johansson plays Irwin's wife, and Gavin Goudey and Roman Engel play their sons. Gary brings Irwin into an environmental consulting business whose first clients are Russian immigrants with a contract to clean the Gowanus Canal. When Irwin alerts them to a safety hazard, he learns that something much dirtier is going on, and his family is in danger, as Common Sense Media summarizes it. We have kept this guide free of spoilers.
Plugged In had not reviewed the film when we wrote this guide, so Common Sense Media is our main parent-guide source. It recommends Paper Tiger for ages 15 and up and calls it a crime thriller about a tight-knit Jewish family in the 1980s that sees a lucrative business opportunity and realizes too late that it is working with gangsters. It says the characters' missteps involve good people with integrity trying to do the right thing, and calls the film wonderfully complex with an unsatisfactory ending. Common Sense lists no sex, romance or nudity.
Language is the most frequent concern. Common Sense lists several uses of the f-word, plus motherf--kers, s--t, bulls--t, a--holes, goddamn, balls, damn and what the hell, an older teen calling someone a d--kweed, and "Jesus" and "Jesus Christ" said as exclamations. We count those uses of Jesus' name under profanity, and Exodus 20:7 is the reason many Christians will notice them. Violence is real but restrained: shootings with blood that Common Sense says are not graphic, a beating, teenage boys threatened with knives and guns, a punch, siblings pushing and shoving, and a car accident with minor bleeding.
Other content is lighter. Characters smoke, drink beer and attend a house party where teenagers drink. A Mercedes is shown as a flashy, desirable symbol of success, and period brands such as Coca-Cola, Tab and Pringles anchor the mid-1980s setting. There is no sexual content and no nudity. We did not find any occult or supernatural content.
The heart of the film is a family of good people. Common Sense says the Pearls, Irwin, his wife, Gary and their two teenage sons, all have integrity, and that the film's themes are family, integrity and sacrifice. The film opens with a line about wealth, "Let there be wealth without tears," which Common Sense uses to ask what integrity is and how each character shows it, and critics read it as a story about the heavy price of pursuing the American Dream too recklessly. The tragedy is that each character's attempt to do right makes the family's problem worse, which is why Common Sense calls it a family tragedy.
Common Sense calls the Pearls a tight-knit Jewish family, and Gray says the film is drawn from his own upbringing. None of the reviews we read describes any religious practice, religious message or treatment of faith, either positive or negative. We therefore have no spiritual content to credit or to weigh, and the only references to Jesus are the exclamations noted above.
The film's central warning is the one in 1 Timothy 6:9-10, that people who want to get rich fall into temptation and a trap, and that the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil. Proverbs 15:27 says that the greedy bring ruin to their households, which describes what happens to the Pearls even though they are not greedy people so much as hopeful ones. Proverbs 22:1 says that a good name is more desirable than great riches, which is the integrity the film's characters try to hold on to. The language runs against Ephesians 4:29, which asks that no unwholesome talk come out of our mouths, so that is a fair thing for a viewer to weigh.
This is an adult drama that Common Sense rates 15 and up, and we would not take younger children. Older teens who watch it could be asked what it costs the family to chase easy money, how each character defines integrity, and whether the ending is just. Parents should know about the frequent profanity, the threats against teenage boys, and the use of Jesus' name as an exclamation, and should watch alone first if any of those are a concern.
Paper Tiger scores 52/100, Mixed. It is a critically admired family tragedy about integrity, sacrifice and the cost of easy money, with no sex or nudity, and it is held back by frequent strong language including misuse of Jesus' name, a restrained but real streak of violence against a family and its teenage sons, and an ending Common Sense finds unsatisfying. It is not a film that attacks faith, and it is not for children. For adults and older teens it is a matter of conscience, and a serious one to talk about afterward.
For other R-rated films we have reviewed, see our guides to Wild Horse Nine, Godzilla Minus Zero and You Can See Everything. Our Christian movie reviews hub and Christian discernment guide explain how we weigh films, and our rating system guide explains the scale. Also opening this week, see Festive Fun with Peppa. For the full parent guide, read Common Sense Media's review.