✦ Discern the Spirit ✦
GODLY SCORE
HomeGuidesShould Christians Watch Presumed Innocent?

Should Christians Watch Presumed Innocent?

Presumed Innocent (Apple TV+, 2024) is the adaptation of Scott Turow's classic legal thriller, starring Jake Gyllenhaal as a prosecutor accused of murdering his colleague and former lover. It is one of Apple TV+'s most-watched originals.

42
GODLY
Presumed Innocent
Caution
2.1/5 · GodlyScore 42/100
Compelling legal thriller built on an adultery premise — the justice system themes are engaging but the show's sympathetic treatment of the affair and its consequences lands in Caution.
View Full Score →

The Legal Thriller Elements

Presumed Innocent is an exceptionally well-made legal thriller. The courtroom sequences, the procedural investigation, and Jake Gyllenhaal's performance are all strong. The show's examination of how the criminal justice system handles accusations against powerful people has genuine relevance and is compelling television.

Proverbs 18:17's observation that 'in a lawsuit the first to speak seems right, until someone comes forward and cross-examines' describes the show's epistemological framework precisely — we are constantly reassessing what we know.

The Adultery Problem

The show's central crime is inseparable from adultery — the affair between the protagonist and the victim is the engine of the entire plot. The show treats this with more moral seriousness than most — the consequences for the protagonist's family are real and shown with weight. But it is a show built around adultery as its foundational situation, and Christians should engage it with awareness of that framing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Presumed Innocent appropriate for Christians?
Caution range (42/100). A well-made legal thriller with genuine substance about the justice system. The show is built around adultery as its foundational situation and treats it with more moral seriousness than most, though not from a biblical framework. Appropriate for mature adults.
Is Presumed Innocent based on a true story?
Presumed Innocent is based on Scott Turow's 1987 bestselling novel — entirely fictional, though Turow drew on his experience as a prosecutor. It was previously adapted as a 1990 film starring Harrison Ford.
Further Reading
Should Christians Watch The Morning Show?Best Christian Shows on Apple TV+Christian TV Reviews
Get More Details on GodlyScore.com

Rate any movie, show, song, or channel for spiritual alignment.

Visit GodlyScore.com →
Related Guides
Should Christians Watch The Morning Show?Should Christians Watch Severance?Should Christians Watch Slow Horses?