✦ Discern the Spirit ✦
GODLY SCORE
HomeGuidesShould Christians Watch You Season 4?

Should Christians Watch You Season 4?

You Season 4 (Netflix, 2023) moves Joe Goldberg to London, where he reinvents himself as a literature professor while a new killer targets the wealthy elite. The show's central trick — making viewers complicit with a murderer — continues in its fourth iteration.

16
GODLY
You Season 4
Avoid
0.8/5 · GodlyScore 16/100
You's fourth season continues making viewers complicit with a serial killer — graphic violence, sexual content, and the ongoing seduction of rooting for a murderer make this firmly Avoid.
View Full Score →

The Show's Central Problem

You's central artistic trick — putting viewers inside the perspective of a charming serial killer and making them root for him — is more problematic in Season 4 than ever. Joe Goldberg has now murdered multiple people across four seasons. The show's continued sympathetic framing of his perspective normalizes violent pathology as a romantic narrative.

This is not a show that depicts a murderer critically — it is a show that invites you to enjoy his perspective. Romans 1:32's warning about those who 'not only continue to do these very things but also approve of those who practice them' is directly relevant to what You asks of its audience.

Season 4 Specifically

Season 4 attempts a meta twist (Joe as detective rather than sole predator) that partially works but doesn't resolve the fundamental issue. Graphic violence continues, sexual content is significant, and the London setting provides fresh visual appeal without addressing the show's core problems.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is You Season 4 appropriate for Christians?
No — You Season 4 scores 16/100 (Avoid). The show asks viewers to identify with and root for a serial killer across four seasons. Graphic violence and sexual content are consistent. The fundamental premise — sympathetic murderer perspective — is the core concern beyond content.
Is You Season 4 better than previous seasons for Christians?
No — it scores lower (16/100) than the original You (18/100). Season 4's attempt at meta-commentary partially works but doesn't resolve the show's fundamental problems and maintains similar graphic content.
Further Reading
Should Christians Watch You on Netflix?Most Anti-Christian Shows on NetflixWorst Shows for ChristiansChristian TV Reviews
Get More Details on GodlyScore.com

Rate any movie, show, song, or channel for spiritual alignment.

Visit GodlyScore.com →
Related Guides
Should Christians Watch You on Netflix?Should Christians Watch Euphoria?Should Christians Watch Dark Desire?