Home›Guides›Common Sense Media vs GodlyScore: What's the Difference?

Common Sense Media vs GodlyScore: What's the Difference?

Name: GodlyScore Review: Common Sense Media vs GodlyScore: What's the Difference?
Item: Common Sense Media vs GodlyScore
Rating: 0.0
Author: GodlyScore

Common Sense Media vs GodlyScore: both help parents evaluate media, but with fundamentally different frameworks. Here is an honest comparison of what each does well — and what each misses.

GODLY

Common Sense Media vs GodlyScore

See Guide

☆☆☆☆☆0.0/5 · GodlyScore 0/100

Common Sense Media provides age-based content ratings from a secular developmental psychology framework. GodlyScore provides biblically-grounded discernment ratings from a Christian perspective. Both are valuable; they answer different questions. For maximum information, use both: CSM for content inventory detail, GodlyScore for biblical discernment framework.

View Full Score →

What Common Sense Media Does Well

Common Sense Media (commonsensemedia.org) is the leading secular media review organization, founded in 2003. It provides detailed, granular content information: age recommendations, specific content descriptions across violence, sexual content, language, drugs, and positive messages. Its reviews are thorough, consistent, and professionally staffed. For parents who want to know "is this developmentally appropriate for my 10-year-old?" it is the gold standard. CSM's strengths: enormous breadth of coverage, granular content descriptions, age-specific recommendations, and comprehensive searchability.

Where Common Sense Media Falls Short for Christians

CSM operates from a secular progressive framework. "Age-appropriate" is determined by developmental psychology and cultural norms — not biblical ethics. This creates systematic blind spots for Christian families:

LGBT normalization: CSM consistently rates LGBT content (same-sex couples, gender identity themes) as positive representation — awarding "positive messages" badges to content that normalizes views incompatible with historic Christian teaching. The presence of a same-sex couple is never flagged as a concern; it is often celebrated as a positive.

Premarital sex: CSM focuses on explicitness, not the biblical category of sexual immorality. A tasteful depiction of an unmarried sexual relationship is not flagged as a concern — only graphic depictions are.

Spiritual content: CSM does not evaluate spiritual content from a Christian perspective. New Age, occult, or pagan spiritual themes may be evaluated positively if they promote tolerance or emotional growth.

How GodlyScore Differs

GodlyScore evaluates media through a specifically biblical framework — asking not just "is this age-appropriate?" but "is this spiritually appropriate?" Nine signal categories (profanity, sexual content, violence, LGBT normalization, spiritual darkness, glorification of sin, deception, virtue strength, redemption arc) are grounded in Scripture. GodlyScore's limitations: less granular content inventory than CSM, and coverage is more limited (650+ guides vs CSM's tens of thousands). The best approach uses both: CSM for content detail, GodlyScore for biblical discernment framework. See our Biblical Discernment Guide and our Plugged In vs GodlyScore comparison. Visit Common Sense Media directly. Our All Guides hub indexes all 650+ GodlyScore reviews.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Common Sense Media and GodlyScore?

Common Sense Media provides age-based content ratings from a secular developmental framework — what is appropriate for children at various ages. GodlyScore provides biblically-grounded discernment ratings — what is spiritually appropriate from a Christian perspective. CSM is more comprehensive in coverage; GodlyScore applies a specifically Christian evaluative framework including LGBT normalization, premarital sex, and spiritual content as concerns. For maximum information, use both.

Is Common Sense Media good for Christian families?

Partially — CSM provides excellent content inventory but operates from a secular progressive framework. It consistently rates LGBT normalization as positive representation, does not flag premarital sex as a concern unless graphically depicted, and does not evaluate spiritual content Christianly. Use CSM for content detail alongside GodlyScore's biblical framework for the complete picture.

Which is better for Christians — Common Sense Media or GodlyScore?

They answer different questions. CSM: 'What content is present and what ages is it appropriate for?' GodlyScore: 'Is this appropriate from a biblical perspective?' CSM is better for comprehensive content inventory. GodlyScore is better for biblical discernment. The best approach uses both — CSM for content detail, GodlyScore for spiritual framework.