Explicit Satan worship depicted approvingly, occult ritual throughout, and deliberate inversion of Christian symbols — firmly in Avoid territory.
The original Sabrina the Teenage Witch (ABC/WB, 1996-2003) was a family-friendly sitcom with mild magical content — essentially a teen comedy where magic was a metaphor for growing up. Chilling Adventures of Sabrina is an entirely different production with an entirely different spirit. Do not let the same character name create a false equivalence. Chilling Adventures of Sabrina is a horror drama based on the Archie Horror comics series. It depicts Sabrina as a half-witch who must choose between the human world and the world of witches — a world that explicitly worships Satan (referred to as the Dark Lord) as a genuine figure of devotion. This is not a metaphor or a sanitized fantasy version of witchcraft. Satan is a character in the show, and witches perform explicit rituals in his honor.
Season 1 of Chilling Adventures of Sabrina involves Sabrina's enrollment in the Academy of Unseen Arts, where students perform a 'Dark Baptism' — a literal signing-away of their soul to Satan. The ceremony is depicted reverently, as a meaningful religious rite. The show features the Black Mass — a Satanic ritual that explicitly inverts the Christian Eucharist — depicted with apparent sincerity. The Church of Night, which the witches practice, is explicitly framed as a religion in opposition to Christianity. The show frames this as liberation rather than condemnation. A Baphomet statue in the school is a real object of satanic iconography. Isaiah 5:20 warns 'Woe to those who call evil good and good evil.' Chilling Adventures of Sabrina does exactly this — presenting Satan worship as feminist empowerment and liberation.
The show presents its Satanic content through a feminist liberation framework — the Church of Night is about women having power that patriarchal Christianity denied them. This framing is deliberate. It is designed to make Satanic worship appealing to young women by tying it to legitimate concerns about gender equality. This is among the most spiritually dangerous content on mainstream streaming — not because it is crude or obviously offensive, but because it is sophisticated, well-produced, and wraps spiritual poison in appealing packaging. 2 Corinthians 11:14 warns that 'Satan himself masquerades as an angel of light.'
Chilling Adventures of Sabrina is one of the clearest cases on the GodlyScore platform where the recommendation is unambiguous: do not watch it. This is not a gray area requiring discernment — it is content that deliberately promotes Satan worship as empowering and desirable, specifically aimed at young women. Christians should not watch it, and parents should be explicit with their children and teenagers about why.
Personal faith and musical content are distinct categories that frequently diverge. GodlyScore evaluates both separately. Key questions: What are the lyrics saying? What worldview do they reflect? Are they consistent with Philippians 4:8 — "whatever is true, noble, right, pure, lovely, admirable"? Score: see full guide.
Engage with specific songs rather than evaluating the artist's name alone. Content varies significantly across albums. See our Christian Musicians hub. The Gospel Coalition provides thoughtful analysis of faith and culture.