Home›Guides›Should Christians Watch American Horror Story?

Should Christians Watch American Horror Story?

Name: GodlyScore Review: Should Christians Watch American Horror Story?
Item: American Horror Story
Rating: 0.3
Author: GodlyScore

American Horror Story is Ryan Murphy's FX anthology horror series, with each season telling a new self-contained story in a different horror genre. It has run since 2011 and spawned multiple spinoffs. For Christians, the assessment is straightforward — this is among the most consistently objectionable content on television.

GODLY

American Horror Story

Avoid

☆☆☆☆☆0.3/5 · GodlyScore 5/100

Graphic violence, explicit sexual content, satanic/occult imagery as entertainment, and active desecration of Christian symbols — among the most objectionable content on cable television.

View Full Score →

Why AHS Is Particularly Problematic for Christians

American Horror Story does not merely contain dark content — it is designed to celebrate darkness as entertainment. Across its many seasons, the show has featured: Coven (Season 3) with witchcraft and satanic imagery as aspirational content for female empowerment; Apocalypse (Season 8) portraying the Antichrist as a sympathetic protagonist; Freak Show (Season 4) with graphic torture; and multiple seasons featuring graphic sexual violence, demonic possession, and occult worship.

Creator Ryan Murphy has explicitly described inserting LGBT content and progressive ideology into mainstream entertainment as a deliberate creative strategy. AHS has been a primary vehicle for this — featuring graphic same-sex sexual content as a consistent element across many seasons.

Ephesians 5:11's instruction to "have nothing to do with the fruitless deeds of darkness, but rather expose them" applies directly here. AHS is not exposing darkness — it is celebrating it as entertainment.

Specific Spiritual Concerns

The Coven and Delicate seasons feature witchcraft as aspirational female power. Apocalypse portrays the Antichrist with sympathy and glamor. Multiple seasons feature inverted crosses, demonic summoning, and satanic ritual as visual aesthetics. This is not horror that opposes evil — it is horror that finds evil beautiful.

Ryan Murphy's creative philosophy of using entertainment to shift cultural attitudes on sexuality and gender makes AHS a vehicle for values formation, not just entertainment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is American Horror Story appropriate for Christians?

No. American Horror Story contains graphic violence, explicit sexual content including same-sex scenes, witchcraft and occult imagery presented as aspirational, and active portrayal of satanic and anti-Christian themes across multiple seasons. It is among the most consistently objectionable content on cable television.

Are any seasons of American Horror Story less problematic?

No season of American Horror Story is appropriate for Christian viewers. While individual seasons vary in their specific content, the overall series consistently features graphic violence, sexual content, and occult/satanic imagery. Murder House (Season 1) is often considered the most 'contained' but still features graphic content.

What is the difference between AHS and Christian horror?

Christian engagement with horror is possible — The Exorcist (38/100) and similar films present supernatural evil as genuinely opposed and ultimately defeated. AHS presents evil as aesthetically beautiful, aspirational, or sympathetic. This distinction between opposing darkness and celebrating it is the key discernment question.