Home›Guides›Is Bethel Music a Christian Band?

Is Bethel Music a Christian Band?

Name: GodlyScore Review: Is Bethel Music a Christian Band?
Item: Bethel Music
Rating: 2.6
Author: GodlyScore

Bethel Music is the worship collective from Bethel Church in Redding, California — led by Bill Johnson. It has produced widely-sung worship songs including 'Goodness of God,' 'Ever Be,' 'No Longer Slaves,' and 'Reckless Love.' Bethel Church has more significant theological concerns than most evangelical megachurches.

GODLY

Bethel Music

Mixed

★★★☆☆2.6/5 · GodlyScore 52/100

Bethel Music's best songs are genuinely powerful worship. The significant concern: Bethel Church promotes Word of Faith and New Apostolic Reformation theology — prophetic words as authoritative, healing guaranteed through faith, gold dust and angel feathers as miraculous signs, and practices that go well beyond biblical Christianity. 'Reckless Love' — their most controversial song — describes God's love as 'reckless,' which many theologians find theologically problematic. 52/100 Mixed.

View Full Score →

What Bethel Music Produces

Bethel Music's songs are musically excellent and many have become widely used in evangelical churches. 'Goodness of God' is a powerful testimony to God's faithfulness. 'No Longer Slaves' engages adoption and freedom from fear with biblical imagery. These songs, evaluated purely on lyrical content, range from sound to excellent.

The Bethel Church Concern

The concern is more significant than Elevation Worship's. Bethel Church under Bill Johnson promotes a theological framework that includes: prophetic words treated as authoritative revelation equal to Scripture, healing guaranteed for all believers through sufficient faith, manifestations like gold dust, angel feathers, and "glory clouds" presented as authentic miraculous signs, and a New Apostolic Reformation framework that places modern-day apostles and prophets in authoritative positions over the church.

These positions have been extensively criticized by evangelical theologians including Michael Horton, Phil Johnson, and others as departures from biblical Christianity. The supernatural manifestations in particular — gold dust on skin, angel feathers appearing during worship — have no biblical warrant and are reminiscent of practices Scripture warns against. See The Gospel Coalition's assessment of Bethel's NAR theology.

The Reckless Love Question

'Reckless Love' by Cory Asbury (Bethel) is the most discussed individual song. The descriptor "reckless" applied to God's love has been criticized as theologically imprecise — God's love is not reckless (heedless of consequences) but deliberately self-giving. This is a genuine theological concern, not just stylistic preference. Many worship leaders have chosen not to use the song for this reason.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Bethel Music a Christian band?

52/100 Mixed. Bethel Music's best songs have sound content and are widely sung. The significant concern: Bethel Church promotes Word of Faith and New Apostolic Reformation theology — prophetic words as revelation, guaranteed healing through faith, gold dust and angel feathers as miraculous signs — that goes well beyond biblical Christianity. 'Reckless Love' has specific theological concerns about describing God's love as reckless.

Should churches use Bethel Music songs?

With discernment. Evaluate each song's content individually — some are theologically sound, others have concerns. Be aware that using Bethel music introduces your congregation to the Bethel brand and may prompt exploration of Bethel Church's theology. Many evangelical churches have chosen to avoid Bethel music specifically due to the NAR and Word of Faith concerns. Safer alternatives: Maverick City Music, CityAlight, or traditional hymns.