A gifted songwriter and compassionate advocate raised a Quaker and now agnostic, but his signature song rewrites sin and salvation around sex against the church with a video of same-sex intimacy, and he is a prominent LGBT advocate, which keeps his score at the floor, though songs like Too Sweet pass the test.
Hozier is Andrew John Hozier-Byrne, born March 17, 1990 and raised in County Wicklow, Ireland. His 2013 debut single "Take Me to Church" peaked at No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100 and made him an international star, and his albums Wasteland, Baby! (2019) and Unreal Unearth (2023, a concept album built on Dante's Inferno) were both major hits. His 2024 single "Too Sweet" reached No. 1 on the Hot 100, and Time named him one of the 100 most influential people in 2025. He is featured on Mumford & Sons' song "Rubber Band Man," from their February 2026 album Prizefighter, and performed with them on Saturday Night Live on February 28, 2026. We found no announcement of a new solo album.
Hozier was raised a Quaker, not a Catholic, and attended a Catholic secondary school, according to Wikipedia, which says he now identifies as agnostic. That matters because the Catholic Church is the target of his best-known song, and he came to it as an outsider in an Ireland where the Catholic Church dominated public life. He told the Evening Standard that he would not call himself an atheist because that is too absolute, but "I don't have any faith." He told Cafébabel "I'm not a religious person," and explained that he uses the language of the Church and the Bible in his songs to make a statement against the Church itself.
His criticism is aimed at institutions and at one teaching in particular. He told the Star Tribune, as quoted by The Pop Song Professor, "I'm not condemning the church or religion on the whole," and said his objection is to its position on same-sex relationships. In an interview quoted by The Christian Post he said he would love to get in trouble with the Catholic Church, and he criticized the phrase "love the sinner, hate the sin." He told Gay Byrne on Irish television that he is not cross about the idea of baptism, per the Irish Examiner. In 2015 he also sang the traditional carol "God Rest You Merry, Gentlemen," which names Christ as Savior, though singing a carol is not a statement of belief.
The song uses the vocabulary of worship, sin and confession to describe sexual love, and it is not a worship song. Plugged In analyzed the lyrics line by line and found that they reject the Bible's teaching that people are born sinful, relabel that sickness as good, and substitute physical intimacy for God as the place of salvation, while the chorus mocks the Church as a source of lies and shame. Hozier told MTV the song is "very much about sexuality," about the sexual act itself, and also a tongue-in-cheek swipe at the Church and organizations that would pontificate over natural humanity and sexual orientation. Plugged In's later review of "Too Sweet" called it bold and basically sacrilegious.
The video makes the political point explicit. Plugged In reports it shows two men kissing and embracing and, by implication, having sex, intercut with footage of hooded men firebombing their home and beating one of them, which Hozier said was inspired by real violence against LGBT youth in Russia. Hozier is not gay, and he told Reuters that people assume he is and that his own orientation is not the point. The sexual content and the attack on Christian teaching are woven together in his signature work.
His other work varies widely. Unreal Unearth follows Dante's nine circles of hell, with songs about lust such as "Francesca," whose lovers are unapologetic about their adultery, and "Eat Your Young," which combines sexual innuendo with a critique of war profiteering. By contrast, Plugged In reviewed "Too Sweet" and found no profanity, no references to sex and nothing to shield your eyes from, only a song about being a night owl who enjoys whiskey. "Cherry Wine" has a video meant to raise awareness of domestic violence, and "Nina Cried Power" honors civil rights artists.
Hozier is a visible advocate on several fronts. Wikipedia reports that he supported the 2018 Irish referendum to repeal the abortion ban, and he released "Swan Upon Leda" in 2022 as a show of solidarity for reproductive rights. He took part in the 2016 Home Sweet Home campaign against homelessness, donated the royalties from "Jackboot Jump" to the NAACP and Black Lives Matter in 2020, performed at the Love Rising benefit for the LGBTQ community in Nashville in 2023, and has called for a ceasefire in Gaza at his shows. Some of these, such as his work for the homeless, reflect concerns Scripture shares, and others conflict with Christian teaching.
Romans 3:23 says that all have sinned and fall short of God's glory, which is the doctrine "Take Me to Church" rejects, and Hebrews 13:4 says marriage should be honored and the marriage bed kept pure, which is the opposite of treating sex as worship. Those are the core disagreements. But Hozier's anger at institutional shame deserves a hearing. The church has sometimes treated people struggling with sexuality with cruelty, and Ephesians 4:15 calls believers to speak the truth in love, which cannot be done by those who are contemptuous. Micah 6:8 calls us to act justly and love mercy, and his advocacy for the homeless echoes it.
For listeners, Philippians 4:8 says to think about what is true, noble, pure and admirable, and 1 Thessalonians 5:21 says to test everything and hold on to what is good. That test gives different answers for different songs, as the contrast between "Take Me to Church" and "Too Sweet" shows.
Hozier scores 1/100, Avoid. He is a gifted lyricist with genuine compassion for the oppressed, and his catalog is not uniformly objectionable. But his signature song deliberately uses Christian worship language against the Church, rewrites sin and salvation around sex, and is paired with a video that depicts same-sex intimacy, and he describes using the language of the Church against the Church as his method. He is also a prominent advocate for LGBT causes, which our scale rates as a major factor. We do not recommend his music for children, and we suggest older listeners judge song by song: "Take Me to Church" is the clearest example of what we caution against, and "Too Sweet" is among the clearest examples of a song that passes. We will review his next solo release when it arrives.
For other artists people ask about, see our guides to David Kushner, Bruno Mars, Olivia Rodrigo, Beyoncé, and Eminem. Our Christian musicians hub and Christian celebrities hub list the rest, and our Christian discernment guide explains how we weigh an artist's faith against their work. For the song's own story, read Wikipedia's article on "Take Me to Church" and the Reuters interview.