Home›Guides›Is The Chosen Biblically Accurate?

Is The Chosen Biblically Accurate?

Name: GodlyScore Review: Is The Chosen Biblically Accurate?
Item: The Chosen
Rating: 4.8
Author: GodlyScore

The Chosen has become the most-watched independently produced series in history, with tens of millions of viewers across its seasons. It is the gold standard of Christian entertainment and scores 98/100 on the GodlyScore. But it also raises genuine questions among careful Christians: how much creative liberty is too much, and can a show add to the biblical narrative without compromising truth?

GODLY

The Chosen

Christ-Centered

★★★★★4.8/5 · GodlyScore 96/100

The gold standard of Christian entertainment — Christ-centered, scripturally grounded, and culturally significant.

View Full Score →

What The Chosen Does That No Other Show Has Done

The Chosen, created by Dallas Jenkins and produced by Angel Studios, has achieved something unprecedented: a multi-season, cinematic portrayal of Jesus' ministry that has reached secular audiences at scale. Season 1 premiered in 2017 and by 2025, Seasons 4 and 5 have continued the story through Jesus' final days with production quality that rivals major studio films.

The central achievement of The Chosen is its portrayal of Jesus as fully human while maintaining his full divinity. Jonathan Roumie's performance captures a Jesus who laughs, weeps, shows frustration, and demonstrates genuine warmth — while never diminishing his authority and divine nature. This is exactly what the Incarnation (John 1:14) describes: 'The Word became flesh and made his dwelling among us.'

Addressing the Accuracy Concerns

The most common Christian concern about The Chosen is its addition of scenes, dialogue, and backstories not found in Scripture. Mary Magdalene's backstory involving demonic oppression and addiction, Peter's fishing business struggles, Nicodemus's private doubts — these are creative extrapolations, not direct biblical text.

Creator Dallas Jenkins has been transparent about this from the beginning: The Chosen is historical fiction inspired by the Gospels, not a word-for-word dramatization. The key question is not whether extra-biblical content is added — it always is in any dramatization — but whether the additions contradict Scripture or illuminate it. On this measure, The Chosen is careful and largely successful. The core theological truths are preserved and often powerfully conveyed.

Season 4 and the Harder Parts of the Story

Season 4 (2024) begins moving toward the events of the Passion — Lazarus is raised, tensions with religious authorities escalate, and the shadow of the cross becomes more present. This territory is handled with care. The show does not shy away from the political and religious forces arraying against Jesus, and the portrayal of Pharisees as complex human beings rather than cartoons is a strength of the series.

Luke 19:10 — 'the Son of Man came to seek and save the lost' — is the beating heart of The Chosen across every season. Every character's story is organized around their encounter with Jesus and the transformation that follows.

The Cultural Opportunity

The Chosen has demonstrated that Jesus-centered content can reach mainstream audiences at scale. Millions of non-Christians have watched it. Christians have used it as an evangelism tool, watching it with non-believing friends and family as a conversation starter. Its accessibility, quality, and emotional resonance make it one of the most useful cultural tools available to the contemporary church. This is not just good television — it is a genuinely significant cultural moment.

The Biblical Framework

Questions about sin fall into two categories: things explicitly called sin in Scripture, and disputable matters (Romans 14-15) where Christians with different convictions should respect each other's consciences. Even when something isn't explicitly sinful: Does this practice reflect Christ's lordship over all of life (Colossians 3:17)? Is it beneficial — not just permissible? (1 Corinthians 10:23). Score: see full guide.

Further Biblical Study

See our Is It a Sin? hub. GotQuestions and the Gospel Coalition provide thorough evangelical analysis.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is The Chosen available for free?

Yes — The Chosen is available for free on the official The Chosen app and website (thechosen.tv). It is also available on Angel Studios' platform. Creator Dallas Jenkins has committed to keeping the show free, funded by viewer crowdfunding and donations.

How many seasons of The Chosen are there?

As of 2025, four seasons have been released with Season 5 in production. The creators have planned seven seasons total, intending to cover Jesus' full ministry through the resurrection and early church.

What are the main biblical accuracy concerns with The Chosen?

The primary concerns involve extra-biblical backstories (Mary Magdalene's past, Peter's family life) and invented dialogue. Creator Dallas Jenkins addresses these directly — all additions are designed to illuminate rather than contradict the biblical text, and the show clearly marks itself as dramatization, not Scripture.

Is The Chosen appropriate for non-Christians?

The Chosen is one of the most effective evangelism tools available to Christians today. It is accessible to people with no church background, emotionally engaging, and presents Jesus compellingly. Many Christians report sharing it with non-believing friends and family members as a conversation starter about faith.